Protected Conversations: What Employees Need to Know
If your employer has requested a meeting to discuss the possibility of ending your employment, you may be about to have what’s known as a “protected conversation.” These discussions can feel daunting, but understanding your rights and what to expect can help you navigate the situation with confidence. This guide explains what protected conversations are, how they work, and what steps you can take to protect your interests.
What is a Protected Conversation?
A protected conversation is a confidential discussion between an employer and an employee about ending the employment relationship on agreed terms. Introduced under Section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996, these conversations are designed to allow employers to propose settlement agreements without the risk of the discussion being used as evidence in an unfair dismissal claim.
In practice, this means your employer can suggest that you leave your job in exchange for a financial settlement (often outlined in a settlement agreement) without formally starting a disciplinary or redundancy process. However, it’s important to know that you are not obliged to accept their offer, and the conversation itself does not mean your employment is being terminated.
Contact Us Today!
Please fill in the form and we will get back to you within 24 hours.
When Can Employers Use Protected Conversations?
Protected conversations are typically used in situations where:
- The employment relationship has broken down.
- There are ongoing performance issues.
- The employer is considering restructuring or redundancies.
However, it’s important to note that protected conversations only apply to ordinary unfair dismissal claims. They do not prevent you from bringing claims related to:
- Automatically unfair dismissal (e.g., if you were dismissed for whistleblowing or asserting a statutory right).
- Discrimination (e.g., based on age, gender, race, disability, religion, or sexual orientation).
- Breach of contract or other statutory rights.
If you believe your employer’s actions fall into one of these categories, anything said during the protected conversation could potentially be used as evidence in a claim.
What Should You Do if Your Employer Initiates a Protected Conversation?
Step 1: Stay Calm and Listen Carefully
- Do not panic: A protected conversation is not a dismissal. Your employer is exploring options, and you have the right to consider their proposal.
- Take notes: Document what is said, including who is present, the reasons given for the offer, and the terms proposed.
- Ask questions: If anything is unclear (e.g., “Why is this being proposed?” or “What happens if I decline?”), seek clarification.
Step 2: Understand the Offer
- Review the details: Employers should explain the rationale for the settlement (e.g., redundancy, performance concerns) and outline the terms. This might include:
- Financial compensation (e.g., lump sum, accrued holiday pay).
- A reference or agreed wording for future job applications.
- Confidentiality clauses.
- Request written confirmation: Ask for the offer in writing to avoid misunderstandings.
Step 3: Do Not Feel Pressured
- You have the right to refuse: A protected conversation is a negotiation, not a termination. Politely decline if you need time to think.
- Watch for red flags: If your employer threatens consequences for refusing (e.g., “It’ll be worse if we go down the formal route”), this could invalidate the “protected” status of the discussion.
Step 4: Request Time to Consider
- Legally, you’re entitled to 10 days: Employers must give you a reasonable period (minimum 10 calendar days) to review the offer and seek advice.
- Negotiate extensions if needed: If the offer is complex or requires further negotiation, ask for additional time.
Step 5: Seek Independent Legal Advice
- This is non-negotiable: For a settlement agreement to be legally valid, you must consult a solicitor. At Solidaire Solicitors, we:
- Assess whether the offer meets your statutory entitlements (e.g., redundancy pay, notice periods).
- Identify hidden risks (e.g., overly broad confidentiality clauses).
- Negotiate better terms on your behalf.
- No cost to you: Employers typically cover your legal fees (up to £1,000 + VAT in most cases).
Step 6: Decide Your Next Move
- Accept the offer: If the terms are fair, we’ll ensure the agreement is signed correctly and your exit is smooth.
- Reject the offer: If you choose to stay, we’ll monitor your employer’s next steps to ensure they follow lawful procedures.
- Report misconduct: If the conversation involved discrimination or coercion, we’ll help you build a claim.
What Are the Risks of Protected Conversations?
While protected conversations are intended to encourage open dialogue, they are not without risks. For example:
- If your employer behaves improperly during the conversation (e.g., by making discriminatory remarks or pressuring you to accept the offer), the protection may be lost, and you could use the conversation as evidence in a claim.
- If you refuse the offer, your employer may decide to start a formal process, such as a performance management or redundancy procedure. However, they must follow fair and lawful procedures in doing so.
What is a Settlement Agreement?
If you and your employer reach an agreement, the terms will usually be set out in a settlement agreement. This is a legally binding document that typically includes:
- The amount of financial compensation you will receive.
- The date your employment will end.
- Any agreed references or other benefits.
- A clause stating that you waive your right to bring certain claims against your employer.
Before signing a settlement agreement, you must receive independent legal advice. This is a legal requirement to ensure the agreement is valid.
Key Takeaways for Employees
- Protected conversations are confidential discussions about ending your employment on agreed terms.
- You are not obliged to accept any offer made during a protected conversation.
- Always seek independent legal advice before agreeing to a settlement.
- If you believe your employer has acted unlawfully, the protection of the conversation may not apply.
How Solidaire Solicitors Can Help
Our team provides end-to-end support:
- Immediate advice: Call us during or after the conversation for real-time guidance.
- Settlement agreement reviews: We’ll scrutinise every clause to protect your interests.
- Negotiation leverage: With our expertise, clients often secure 20-30% higher payouts than initial offers.
- Tribunal representation: If your employer acts unlawfully post-conversation, we’ll fight for your rights in court.
Why Trust Solidaire Solicitors?
✅ Proven Track Record: We’ve successfully negotiated settlements for hundreds of employees across the UK, securing improved terms in over 90% of cases.
✅ Transparent Communication: We explain complex legal terms in plain English and keep you updated at every stage.
✅ Fixed-Fee Services: Clear pricing with no hidden costs—ask about our competitive rates for settlement agreement reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
A: A protected conversation is a confidential discussion between an employer and employee about ending the employment relationship on agreed terms. Under UK law (Section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996), these conversations cannot generally be used as evidence in an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. Employers often use them to propose a settlement agreement, such as financial compensation in exchange for leaving the job.
A: Employers may propose a protected conversation if they want to resolve a sensitive issue without formal processes. Common scenarios include:
- A breakdown in the working relationship.
- Concerns about performance.
- Restructuring or redundancy considerations.
The goal is to reach a mutually agreed exit, but you are not obligated to accept the offer.
A: No. A protected conversation is not a dismissal, and you have the right to refuse the offer. If you decline, your employer may choose to start a formal process (e.g., performance management or redundancy consultations), but they must follow fair procedures.
A: If you reject the settlement proposal, your employment continues as normal. However, your employer could decide to pursue formal action (e.g., disciplinary procedures or redundancy consultations). They must act lawfully and avoid retaliation, as this could lead to a separate claim.
A: They are confidential only for ordinary unfair dismissal claims. If you later bring a claim for discrimination, whistleblowing, breach of contract, or other statutory rights, anything said during the conversation could be used as evidence.
A: If you feel pressured, bullied, or discriminated against, document the details and seek legal advice immediately. Improper conduct (e.g., threats or discriminatory remarks) can invalidate the “protected” status, allowing you to use the conversation in a claim.
A: A settlement agreement is a legally binding contract that sets out the terms for ending your employment. It typically includes financial compensation, a reference, and a clause waiving your right to bring certain claims. You must receive independent legal advice for the agreement to be valid.
A: Employers usually contribute to your legal fees (often between £350-£500 + VAT). Your solicitor will review the agreement, explain its implications, and negotiate better terms if necessary.
A: You should be given at least 10 calendar days to consider the offer and seek advice. If your employer tries to rush you, this could be seen as coercive behaviour.
A: If you are dismissed after refusing a settlement offer, you may have grounds for an unfair dismissal claim. However, the protected conversation itself cannot be cited as evidence in an ordinary unfair dismissal case. If the dismissal relates to discrimination, whistleblowing, or other unlawful reasons, the conversation may still be admissible.
A: Yes. Employees can suggest a settlement discussion, but employers are not obligated to agree. If you raise the issue, the same confidentiality rules apply.
A: An employment solicitor can:
- Advise on the fairness of the settlement offer.
- Negotiate better terms (e.g., higher compensation or a stronger reference).
- Ensure your rights are protected if the conversation turns contentious.
- Represent you in claims if the protected conversation rules are misused.
Get in Touch!
Please fill in the form and we will get back to you within 24 hours.
